Free shipping on orders over $75 for US customers!

Take control of your food supply and protect your family in an emergency!

Take control of your food supply and protect your family in case of an emergency

Presto Pressure Canner or All American Pressure Canner: Which is Better?

In the world of home canning, the choice of a pressure canner can make a significant difference in the quality and safety of your preserved foods. Two prominent brands, Presto and All American, have earned their place in the hearts of home canners. But when it comes to Presto vs. All American, which one should you choose?

Let's explore the key aspects of both and help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Pressure Canning

Before delving into the Presto vs. All American showdown, let's understand why pressure canning matters. Pressure canners are essential for preserving low-acid foods like vegetables, meats, and poultry. They use a combination of pressure and heat to kill harmful microorganisms and create a vacuum seal that keeps your food safe and shelf-stable.

NOTE: For any style of canning, water-bath or pressure, it is important to know your altitude as your altitude will affect the time of canning for water-bath canning and the pounds of pressure for pressure canning.

Presto Pressure Canners

Presto is a name familiar to many home canners. They offer a range of pressure canners in various sizes to suit different needs. Presto canners are known for being budget-friendly and user-friendly. Let's take a closer look:

Key Features:

Materials: Presto canners are typically made of aluminum, making them lightweight and affordable.

Sizes: They offer a variety of sizes, from 16 to 23 quarts, catering to both small and large canning projects.

Price Range: Presto canners are often more budget-friendly compared to All American counterparts.

For the traditional Presto Pressure canner you will need to replace the gasket
from time to time, so that is something to consider in your purchase.

All American Pressure Canners

All American pressure canners are synonymous with durability and precision. They are built to last and are favored by serious canners. I personally invested in an All-American Pressure Canner because I wanted a canner that would last forever and required no maintenance like purchasing gaskets. Here's what you need to know:

Key Features:

Materials: All American canners are constructed from heavy-duty cast aluminum or stainless steel, ensuring long-term durability.

Sizes: They come in larger sizes, with capacities ranging from 10.5 to 41.5 quarts, perfect for extensive canning endeavors.

Price Range: All American canners are an investment, with a higher price point than Presto models.

Presto vs. All American: A Detailed Comparison

Durability and Build Quality:

Presto: While Presto canners are sturdy, their aluminum construction is not as robust as the stainless steel used in All American models.

All American: These canners are built like tanks, and their stainless steel options are incredibly durable.

Precision and Ease of Use:

Presto: Presto canners often use a weighted gauge system, which simplifies pressure regulation but may not offer the precision of a dial gauge.

All American: All American canners come equipped with precise dial gauges, allowing for more accurate pressure control.

Safety Features and Longevity:

Presto: Presto canners have safety features, but their longevity may not match that of All American canners.

All American: These canners feature multiple safety mechanisms and are known for their long lifespan, often passed down through generations.

User Experiences and Reviews

User experiences vary, but both brands have their dedicated followers. Presto is often praised for its affordability and ease of use, while All American receives accolades for its durability and precise canning capabilities. Personal preferences play a significant role here.

Budget Considerations

Your budget is a crucial factor in this decision. If you're just starting with canning or have limited funds, Presto offers an accessible entry point. However, if you're willing to invest in a pressure canner that will last a lifetime, All American is worth considering.

Specialized Needs

Consider your canning volume and specific requirements. If you have a large garden and plan extensive canning, the larger sizes of All American canners might be more practical. However, for smaller batches, Presto canners can get the job done efficiently.

If you have an electric or glass stovetop, you most definitely would want to use a digital pressure canner as compared to a traditional pressure canner. One advantage that Presto has over All-American is that it offers a digital pressure canner. Weighted-gauge pressure canners are heavy and can crack glass stove-tops. Additionally, heat is hard to control on an electric stovetop, so a digital pressure canner is the way to go.

Maintenance and Care

Proper maintenance and care are essential for the longevity of your pressure canner, regardless of the brand. Regularly inspect seals, gauges, and vent pipes, and follow the manufacturer's instructions for cleaning and storage.

In the Presto vs. All American debate, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. The choice ultimately depends on your budget, canning needs, and personal preferences. Presto offers affordability and ease of use, while All American provides durability and precision. Consider your priorities and make an informed decision based on what matters most to you.


1. Can I use a Presto pressure canner for extensive canning projects?

Yes, Presto offers larger sizes suitable for large-scale canning, but All American's larger models might be more durable for heavy use.

2. Are All American canners worth the higher price?

If durability and precise pressure control are essential to you, the investment in an All American canner may be justified.

3. Can Presto canners last a long time with proper care?

With proper maintenance, Presto canners can serve you well, but All American canners are renowned for their long lifespan.

4. Are there safety risks with Presto canners?

Presto canners have safety features, but All American canners often come with additional safety mechanisms.

5. Which brand is better for beginners?

 Presto is often recommended for beginners due to its user-friendly design and lower price point.

Presto Pressure Canner or All American Pressure Canner: Which is Better?